"Just look at yourself, crammed into that box, no longer master of your fate, and doomed to repeat forever and ever the mistake you yourself made, when you asked for immortality and didn't specify the conditions."
"I didn't make any mistake at all. And I'm very happy whenever I can grant someone their heart's desire."
"And that desire is filled with poison, the twisting agony of regret, and grief unending."
"I told you it made me happy," said the thing, and fell silent.
"Just plain malicious," said Auntie~~Judith Merkle Riley's The Master of All Desires~~ Sibille Artaud de la Roque is in trouble. At a the dried-up age of twenty-two, she has been plucked from the convent and her dream of a life devoted to Art in order to be forge an alliance with a powerful neighbor. But several months, and an
entirely forgivable misunderstanding later, has found her fleeing towards her rich aunt in Orléans to escape the scandal of shooting her would-be paramour in the face.
France, in 1556, is at the mercy of its own internal upheavals. As the Church is threatened by the struggle to return England to the true faith, the Bourbons and and Guises struggle for dominance and the promise of uniting three kingdoms under French rule. Henri II openly scorns his wife, Catherine de Medici, for his mistress Diane de Poitiers, causing the two women to become locked in an unending power play, with all the noblewomen as pawns in their own quest for influence over the royal monarch.
These two worlds, an ex-convent girl living with an eccentric widow in Orléans and the glittering court of Paris, could not be more removed from one another. But the gap is about to be bridged: for into the unwitting hands of Sibille Artaud de la Roque has fallen a very special silver casket. In this box lies the Undying Head of Menander, who now exists only to tempt others and eat away at souls as he grants impossible wishes, but only to further misery. Otherwise known -- to the schemers and sorcerers and power-mad of France -- as the Master of All Desires.
There's a fantastic 16-century ballad, "Mary Hamilton," in which a lady in waiting is accused of murdering the child she's had by the king. I used to listen to Joan Baez's version incessantly, curled up with my ear almost pressed to the stereo speaker. Mary Hamilton rides into Glasgow, sent to the gallows, in white gown as if for a wedding. The crowds weep as she passes and she refuses it, telling them it's fit punishment for the crime. And she muses aloud at the changes in her fate: from Queen's favorite to convict in a night. As she's standing there in her petticoat and blindfolded, the king himself rides up and grants she may be pardoned and come down, as long as she comes to
him.
To which she replies (if you'll forgive some paraphrasing): fuck you. Fuck you, and fuck the horse you rode in on. Fuck your
pity. Fuck your fucked-up court, its fucked morals and how the powerful bend everything and everyone in it to their slightest whim. I would rather put my newborn child in a boat on the river and set him adrift to Fate than have him live in it. If you cared about my life, you never would have touched me.
Then she dies.
I kept hearing this song in my head as I read though
The Master of All Desires. It's a nice bookend to
The Oracle Glass, in which the power struggles are touched upon but the real role of the aristocracy is to oppress those beneath them. In
Master we get up close and personal with Henri II's court -- and it's like turning over a rock to find a slew of worms frantically copulating in the dirt.
This isn't a romance. There is
a romance, but it develops over something like two pages, and the book is better for it --
Master is reminiscent of a Shakespearean play, half comedy of manners and half historical tragedy. All the comedy and romance is played out amongst the lesser nobility, and they engage in the kind of romps which makes
Oracle so fabulous: love potions, poisonings, vengeful ghosts, fencing societies, helpful Spirits of History, poetry readings, etc. Riley ups the ante by playing what I can only call the literary equivalent of button-button-who's-got-the-button with a variety of objects pertinent to the plot. Now Nicholas has the poisoned love potion! Now Sibelle! Now so-and-so has intercepted Nostradamus' letter! It's marvelous, the amount of fun she (and hopefully her reader) is having.
And then we have the second cast: the movers and shakers of the French court. They enact the tragic portion of the story. And let me tell you, anytime you're thinking, gee, I wish I lived in the time of chivalry as a powerful and moneyed aristocrat? Pick up this book. It will deliver a much-needed dose of Wow, So Not Worth It.
It's dark stuff, this part of history. Riley has a lot to slog through, and although she adds it to the main narrative with her customary light touch it can still feel like a history pop quiz unless you're already familiar with the French Wars of Religion and events leading up to it. I admit to my eyes glazing at certain passages. But I would argue that as long as you know about
the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre, Riley's got your back.
She tempers all of this with the comedic plotline -- Sibille and her aunt, and Nostradamus (!! I forgot to work him in! He's in here, puttering about.) and all their families and friends. Sibille is utterly unlike Genevieve -- moony, a trifle self-important -- but still sympathetic and worthwhile, and like with Genevieve this book is very much about her evolution as a person. Anyone who likes Pratchett's Nanny Ogg should really meet Aunt Pauline. (Whom
I love much better.) She is filthy rich and haunted by ghosts and knows how to shop. This whole plotline is dominated by a much-needed levity which lovingly mocks the younger characters and their dramatic inner monologues. Any scene where Auntie and her ancient friends discuss Sibille's love life is absolutely worth the price of admission.
And while the darkness inherent in the historical plotline encroaches here, as well, part of Sibille's growth is about learning to live with darkness as well as light. If there is any real message to be gained from
The Master of All Desires, it might be that throughout the trials and tribulations of history, despite the sorrows and setbacks we suffer in our small lives, there is one constant. Life? Goes on.